Source profileQuality 90/100Review permissions

affaan-m/ECC/skills/windows-desktop-e2e/SKILL.md

windows-desktop-e2e

E2E testing for Windows native desktop apps (WPF, WinForms, Win32/MFC, Qt) using pywinauto and Windows UI Automation.

Source repository stars
234,327
Declared platforms
0
Static risk flags
2
Last source update
2026-07-27
Source checked
2026-07-28

Decision brief

What it does—and where it fits

End-to-end testing for Windows native desktop applications using pywinauto backed by Windows UI Automation (UIA). Covers WPF, WinForms, Win32/MFC, and Qt (5.x / 6.x) — with Qt-specific guidance as a dedicated section.

Best for

    Not for

    • Tasks that require unconfirmed production actions or broad system permissions.
    • Environments where the pinned source and install steps cannot be inspected.

    Compatibility matrix

    Platform support, with evidence labels

    PlatformStatusEvidenceWhat to check
    CodexNot declaredNo explicit evidencePortability before use
    Claude CodeNot declaredNo explicit evidencePortability before use
    CursorNot declaredNo explicit evidencePortability before use
    Gemini CLINot declaredNo explicit evidencePortability before use
    Open the compatibility checker

    Installation

    Inspect first. Install second.

    The source command is displayed only when detected. A safe inspection prompt is always available so your agent can explain every action before execution.

    Source-detected install commandSource
    npx skills add https://github.com/affaan-m/ECC --skill "skills/windows-desktop-e2e"
    Safe inspection promptEditorial

    Inspect the Agent Skill "windows-desktop-e2e" from https://github.com/affaan-m/ECC/blob/4e973d3eaf92d97f8d2e2d8abb39d8bdc8711b38/skills/windows-desktop-e2e/SKILL.md at commit 4e973d3eaf92d97f8d2e2d8abb39d8bdc8711b38. List every install step, command, network request, credential, file read/write, external action, and rollback step. Explain whether it fits my task. Do not install or execute anything until I approve.

    Workflow

    What the source asks the agent to do

    1. 01

      Setup & Prerequisites

      Review the “Setup & Prerequisites” section in the pinned source before continuing.

      Review and apply the “Setup & Prerequisites” source section.
    2. 02

      Testability Setup (by Framework)

      The single most impactful thing you can do is give every interactive control a stable AutomationId before writing tests.

      The single most impactful thing you can do is give every interactive control a stable AutomationId before writing tests.
    3. 03

      Per-Step Trace (opt-in)

      The default failure screenshot is often too thin for diagnosing flaky tests. The step-level trace below is off by default — enable it only when reproducing a flaky case.

      The default failure screenshot is often too thin for diagnosing flaky tests. The step-level trace below is off by default — enable it only when reproducing a flaky case.bash E2ETRACE=1 pytest tests/testlogin.py -v
    4. 04

      Tier 2 — Windows Job Object (optional: process-lifetime containment)

      Attach the process to a Job Object so it is automatically terminated when the test fixture's job handle is GC'd. Also prevents the app from spawning child processes that escape fixture cleanup.

      spawning processes outside the job (LIMITKILLONJOBCLOSE)Attach the process to a Job Object so it is automatically terminated when the test fixture's job handle is GC'd. Also prevents the app from spawning child processes that escape fixture cleanup.Scope of isolation: Job Objects do NOT virtualize filesystem access or block network traffic. File-write and network isolation require AppContainer, Windows Firewall rules, or Tier 3 (Windows Sandbox). Use Tier 2 only f…
    5. 05

      GOOD: fresh process per test (or per class at most)

      @pytest.fixture(scope="function") def app(): ... bash

      @pytest.fixture(scope="function") def app(): ... bash

    Permission review

    Static risk signals and limitations

    Runs scripts

    medium · line 47

    The documentation asks the agent to run terminal commands or scripts.

    # Python 3.8+, Windows only

    Network access

    medium · line 50

    The documentation includes network, browsing, or remote request actions.

    # Install ffmpeg and add to PATH: https://ffmpeg.org/download.html

    Evidence record

    Why each signal appears

    EvidenceSourceComputedTestedEditorial
    SignalValueEvidence typeMeaning
    Quality score90/100ComputedDocumentation, specificity, maintenance, and trust rules
    Repository stars234,327SourceRepository attention, not individual Skill quality
    Compatibility0 platformsSourceDeclared in the catalog source record
    Usage guideautomated source guideEditorialGenerated or reviewed according to the visible evidence level

    Pinned source

    Provenance and original SKILL.md

    Repository
    affaan-m/ECC
    Skill path
    skills/windows-desktop-e2e/SKILL.md
    Commit
    4e973d3eaf92d97f8d2e2d8abb39d8bdc8711b38
    License
    MIT
    Collected
    2026-07-28
    Default branch
    main
    View the original SKILL.md

    Windows Desktop E2E Testing

    End-to-end testing for Windows native desktop applications using pywinauto backed by Windows UI Automation (UIA). Covers WPF, WinForms, Win32/MFC, and Qt (5.x / 6.x) — with Qt-specific guidance as a dedicated section.

    When to Activate

    • Writing or running E2E tests for a Windows native desktop application
    • Setting up a desktop GUI test suite from scratch
    • Diagnosing flaky or failing desktop automation tests
    • Adding testability (AutomationId, accessible names) to an existing app
    • Integrating desktop E2E into a CI/CD pipeline (GitHub Actions windows-latest)

    When NOT to Use

    • Web applications → use e2e-testing skill (Playwright)
    • Electron / CEF / WebView2 apps → the HTML layer needs browser automation, not UIA
    • Mobile apps → use platform-specific tools (UIAutomator, XCUITest)
    • Pure unit or integration tests that don't need a running GUI

    Core Concepts

    All Windows desktop automation relies on UI Automation (UIA), a Windows-built-in accessibility API. Every supported framework exposes a tree of UIA elements with properties Claude can read and act on:

    Your test (Python)
        └── pywinauto (UIA backend)
            └── Windows UI Automation API   ← built into Windows, framework-agnostic
                └── App's UIA provider      ← each framework ships its own
                    └── Running .exe
    

    UIA quality by framework:

    FrameworkAutomationIdReliabilityNotes
    WPF5/5Excellentx:Name maps directly to AutomationId
    WinForms4/5GoodAccessibleName = AutomationId
    UWP / WinUI 35/5ExcellentFull Microsoft support
    Qt 6.x5/5ExcellentAccessibility enabled by default; class names change to Qt6*
    Qt 5.15+4/5GoodImproved Accessibility module
    Qt 5.7–5.143/5FairNeeds QT_ACCESSIBILITY=1; objectName manual
    Win32 / MFC3/5FairControl IDs accessible; text matching common

    Setup & Prerequisites

    # Python 3.8+, Windows only
    pip install pywinauto pytest pytest-html Pillow pytest-timeout
    # Optional: screen recording
    # Install ffmpeg and add to PATH: https://ffmpeg.org/download.html
    

    Verify UIA is reachable:

    from pywinauto import Desktop
    Desktop(backend="uia").windows()  # lists all top-level windows
    

    Install Accessibility Insights for Windows (free, from Microsoft) — your DevTools equivalent for inspecting the UIA element tree before writing any test.

    Testability Setup (by Framework)

    The single most impactful thing you can do is give every interactive control a stable AutomationId before writing tests.

    WPF

    <!-- XAML: x:Name becomes AutomationId automatically -->
    <TextBox x:Name="usernameInput" />
    <PasswordBox x:Name="passwordInput" />
    <Button x:Name="btnLogin" Content="Login" />
    <TextBlock x:Name="lblError" />
    

    WinForms

    // Set in designer or code
    usernameInput.AccessibleName = "usernameInput";
    passwordInput.AccessibleName = "passwordInput";
    btnLogin.AccessibleName = "btnLogin";
    lblError.AccessibleName = "lblError";
    

    Win32 / MFC

    // Control resource IDs in .rc file are exposed as AutomationId strings
    // IDC_EDIT_USERNAME -> AutomationId "1001"
    // Prefer SetWindowText for Name; add IAccessible for richer support
    

    Qt — see dedicated section below


    Page Object Model

    tests/
    ├── conftest.py          # app launch fixture, failure screenshot
    ├── pytest.ini
    ├── config.py
    ├── pages/
    │   ├── __init__.py      # required for imports
    │   ├── base_page.py     # locators, wait, screenshot helpers
    │   ├── login_page.py
    │   └── main_page.py
    ├── tests/
    │   ├── __init__.py
    │   ├── test_login.py
    │   └── test_main_flow.py
    └── artifacts/           # screenshots, videos, logs
    

    base_page.py

    import os, time
    from pywinauto import Desktop
    from config import ACTION_TIMEOUT, ARTIFACT_DIR
    
    class BasePage:
        def __init__(self, window):
            self.window = window
    
        # --- Locators (priority order) ---
    
        def by_id(self, auto_id, **kw):
            """AutomationId — most stable. Use as first choice."""
            return self.window.child_window(auto_id=auto_id, **kw)
    
        def by_name(self, name, **kw):
            """Visible text / accessible name."""
            return self.window.child_window(title=name, **kw)
    
        def by_class(self, cls, index=0, **kw):
            """Control class + index — fragile, avoid if possible."""
            return self.window.child_window(class_name=cls, found_index=index, **kw)
    
        # --- Waits ---
    
        def wait_visible(self, spec, timeout=ACTION_TIMEOUT):
            spec.wait("visible", timeout=timeout)
            return spec
    
        def wait_gone(self, spec, timeout=ACTION_TIMEOUT):
            spec.wait_not("visible", timeout=timeout)
            return spec
    
        def wait_window(self, title, timeout=ACTION_TIMEOUT):
            """Wait for a new top-level window (dialogs, child windows)."""
            dlg = Desktop(backend="uia").window(title=title)
            dlg.wait("visible", timeout=timeout)
            return dlg
    
        def wait_until(self, fn, timeout=ACTION_TIMEOUT, interval=0.3):
            """Poll an arbitrary condition — use when UIA events are unreliable."""
            deadline = time.time() + timeout
            while time.time() < deadline:
                try:
                    if fn():
                        return True
                except Exception:
                    pass
                time.sleep(interval)
            raise TimeoutError(f"Condition not met within {timeout}s")
    
        # --- Actions ---
    
        def click(self, spec):
            self.wait_visible(spec)
            spec.click_input()
    
        def type_text(self, spec, text):
            self.wait_visible(spec)
            ctrl = spec.wrapper_object()
            try:
                ctrl.set_edit_text(text)
            except Exception as e:
                # Qt 5.x fallback: UIA Value Pattern may be incomplete
                import sys, pywinauto.keyboard as kb
                print(f"[windows-desktop-e2e] set_edit_text failed ({e}), using keyboard fallback", file=sys.stderr)
                ctrl.click_input()
                kb.send_keys("^a")
                kb.send_keys(text, with_spaces=True)
    
        def get_text(self, spec):
            ctrl = spec.wrapper_object()
            for attr in ("window_text", "get_value"):
                try:
                    v = getattr(ctrl, attr)()
                    if v:
                        return v
                except Exception:
                    pass
            return ""
    
        # --- Artifacts ---
    
        def screenshot(self, name):
            os.makedirs(ARTIFACT_DIR, exist_ok=True)
            path = os.path.join(ARTIFACT_DIR, f"{name}.png")
            self.window.capture_as_image().save(path)
            return path
    

    login_page.py

    from pages.base_page import BasePage
    
    class LoginPage(BasePage):
        @property
        def username(self): return self.by_id("usernameInput")
    
        @property
        def password(self): return self.by_id("passwordInput")
    
        @property
        def btn_login(self): return self.by_id("btnLogin")
    
        @property
        def error_label(self): return self.by_id("lblError")
    
        def login(self, user, pwd):
            self.type_text(self.username, user)
            self.type_text(self.password, pwd)
            self.click(self.btn_login)
    
        def login_ok(self, user, pwd, main_title="Main Window"):
            self.login(user, pwd)
            return self.wait_window(main_title)
    
        def login_fail(self, user, pwd):
            self.login(user, pwd)
            self.wait_visible(self.error_label)
            return self.get_text(self.error_label)
    

    conftest.py

    For new projects prefer the Tier 1 sandbox fixture (see below) — it adds filesystem isolation at zero extra cost. This basic fixture is for minimal/legacy setups only.

    import os, pytest
    os.environ["QT_ACCESSIBILITY"] = "1"  # Required for Qt 5.x UIA support
    
    from pywinauto import Application
    from config import APP_PATH, MAIN_WINDOW_TITLE, LAUNCH_TIMEOUT, ARTIFACT_DIR
    
    @pytest.fixture
    def app(request):
        if not APP_PATH:
            pytest.exit("APP_PATH environment variable is not set", returncode=1)
        proc = Application(backend="uia").start(APP_PATH, timeout=LAUNCH_TIMEOUT)
        win  = proc.window(title=MAIN_WINDOW_TITLE)
        win.wait("visible", timeout=LAUNCH_TIMEOUT)
        yield win
        # Screenshot on failure
        if getattr(getattr(request.node, "rep_call", None), "failed", False):
            os.makedirs(ARTIFACT_DIR, exist_ok=True)
            try:
                win.capture_as_image().save(
                    os.path.join(ARTIFACT_DIR, f"FAIL_{request.node.name}.png")
                )
            except Exception:
                pass
        # Graceful exit first, force-kill as fallback
        # proc is a pywinauto Application — use wait_for_process_exit(), not wait_for_process()
        try:
            win.close()
            proc.wait_for_process_exit(timeout=5)
        except Exception:
            proc.kill()
    
    @pytest.hookimpl(tryfirst=True, hookwrapper=True)
    def pytest_runtest_makereport(item, call):
        outcome = yield
        setattr(item, f"rep_{outcome.get_result().when}", outcome.get_result())
    

    config.py

    import os
    APP_PATH          = os.environ.get("APP_PATH", "")           # set via env — no default path
    MAIN_WINDOW_TITLE = os.environ.get("APP_TITLE", "")
    LAUNCH_TIMEOUT    = int(os.environ.get("LAUNCH_TIMEOUT", "15"))
    ACTION_TIMEOUT    = int(os.environ.get("ACTION_TIMEOUT", "10"))
    ARTIFACT_DIR      = os.path.join(os.path.dirname(__file__), "artifacts")
    

    pytest.ini

    [pytest]
    testpaths = tests
    markers =
        smoke: fast smoke tests for critical paths
        flaky: known-unstable tests
    addopts = -v --tb=short --html=artifacts/report.html --self-contained-html
    

    Locator Strategy

    AutomationId  >  Name (text)  >  ClassName + index  >  XPath
      (stable)         (readable)       (fragile)           (last resort)
    

    Inspect with Accessibility Insights → Properties pane → look for AutomationId first.

    # Inspect at runtime — paste into a REPL to explore the tree
    win.print_control_identifiers()
    # or narrow scope:
    win.child_window(auto_id="groupBox1").print_control_identifiers()
    

    Wait Patterns

    # Wait for control to appear
    page.wait_visible(page.by_id("statusLabel"))
    
    # Wait for control to disappear (e.g. loading spinner)
    page.wait_gone(page.by_id("spinnerOverlay"))
    
    # Wait for a dialog to pop up
    dlg = page.wait_window("Confirm Delete")
    
    # Custom condition (e.g. text changes)
    page.wait_until(lambda: page.get_text(page.by_id("lblStatus")) == "Ready")
    

    Never use time.sleep() as primary synchronization — use wait() or wait_until().

    Artifact Management

    # Screenshot on demand
    page.screenshot("after_login")
    
    # Full-screen capture (when window is off-screen or minimised)
    import pyautogui
    pyautogui.screenshot("artifacts/fullscreen.png")
    
    # Screen recording with ffmpeg (start before test, stop after)
    import subprocess
    
    def start_recording(name):
        return subprocess.Popen([
            "ffmpeg", "-f", "gdigrab", "-framerate", "10",
            "-i", "desktop", "-y", f"artifacts/videos/{name}.mp4"
        ], stdin=subprocess.PIPE, stdout=subprocess.DEVNULL, stderr=subprocess.DEVNULL)
    
    def stop_recording(proc):
        proc.stdin.write(b"q"); proc.stdin.flush(); proc.wait(timeout=10)
    

    Per-Step Trace (opt-in)

    The default failure screenshot is often too thin for diagnosing flaky tests. The step-level trace below is off by default — enable it only when reproducing a flaky case.

    Enable

    E2E_TRACE=1 pytest tests/test_login.py -v
    # Include typed text in the JSONL log (DO NOT use on tests that type credentials/PII):
    E2E_TRACE=1 E2E_TRACE_INCLUDE_TEXT=1 pytest ...
    

    Patch into BasePage

    import os, json, time
    TRACE_ENABLED      = os.environ.get("E2E_TRACE") == "1"
    TRACE_INCLUDE_TEXT = os.environ.get("E2E_TRACE_INCLUDE_TEXT") == "1"
    
    class BasePage:
        _step = 0
    
        def _trace(self, action, spec=None, text=None):
            if not TRACE_ENABLED:
                return
            BasePage._step += 1
            idx = f"{BasePage._step:03d}"
            os.makedirs(ARTIFACT_DIR, exist_ok=True)
            try:
                self.window.capture_as_image().save(
                    os.path.join(ARTIFACT_DIR, f"step_{idx}_{action}.png"))
            except Exception:
                pass  # capture failure must not break the test
            rec = {
                "ts": time.time(), "step": BasePage._step, "action": action,
                "locator": getattr(spec, "criteria", None),
                "text": text if TRACE_INCLUDE_TEXT else ("<redacted>" if text else None),
            }
            with open(os.path.join(ARTIFACT_DIR, "trace.jsonl"), "a") as f:
                f.write(json.dumps(rec) + "\n")
    
        def click(self, spec):
            self.wait_visible(spec); self._trace("click_before", spec)
            spec.click_input();      self._trace("click_after",  spec)
    
        def type_text(self, spec, text):
            self.wait_visible(spec); self._trace("type_before", spec, text)
            # ... existing set_edit_text / keyboard fallback ...
            self._trace("type_after", spec)
    

    Caveats

    • PII / credentials: type_text content is <redacted> by default. Never set E2E_TRACE_INCLUDE_TEXT=1 on login or payment flows.
    • Overhead: ~50–200ms per action + one PNG per step on disk. Don't enable on the default CI matrix — only on a dedicated flake-repro job.
    • Artifact bloat: a long flow produces tens of MB; tune retention-days accordingly.
    • Parallel/rerun hygiene: this simple example appends to trace.jsonl and uses a class-level counter. Clear the artifact directory before reruns, and use per-worker artifact dirs for parallel tests.
    • Coverage gap: actions performed outside BasePage (raw pywinauto calls in test code) are not traced.

    Flaky Test Handling

    # Quarantine — equivalent to Playwright's test.fixme()
    @pytest.mark.skip(reason="Flaky: animation race on slow CI. Issue #42")
    def test_animated_transition(self, app): ...
    
    # Skip in CI only
    @pytest.mark.skipif(os.environ.get("CI") == "true", reason="Flaky in CI #43")
    def test_heavy_load(self, app): ...
    

    Common causes and fixes:

    CauseFix
    Control not readyReplace time.sleep with wait_visible
    Window not focusedAdd win.set_focus() before interactions
    Animation in progresswait_until(lambda: not loading_indicator.exists())
    Dialog timingwait_window(title, timeout=15)
    CI display not readySet DISPLAY or use virtual desktop in CI
    set_edit_text raises NotImplementedErrorUIA ValuePattern missing (common on Qt 5.x) — BasePage.type_text already falls back to keyboard.send_keys
    Control exists but wait_visible times outWindow minimised or off-screen — call win.restore() + win.set_focus() before waiting

    Test Isolation & Sandbox

    Three tiers of isolation — use the lightest tier that satisfies your needs.

    Tier 1 — Filesystem Isolation (default, always use)

    Each test gets its own APPDATA / LOCALAPPDATA / TEMP via subprocess.Popen and Application.connect(). pytest's tmp_path fixture handles cleanup automatically.

    # conftest.py — replace the basic `app` fixture with this
    import os, subprocess, pytest
    from pywinauto import Application
    from config import APP_PATH, APP_ARGS, APP_TITLE, LAUNCH_TIMEOUT, ACTION_TIMEOUT, ARTIFACT_DIR
    
    @pytest.fixture(scope="function")
    def app(request, tmp_path):
        """Fresh process + isolated user-data dirs per test."""
        if not APP_PATH:
            pytest.exit("APP_PATH not set", returncode=1)
    
        # Redirect all per-user storage to an isolated tmp directory
        sandbox_env = os.environ.copy()
        sandbox_env["QT_ACCESSIBILITY"]  = "1"
        sandbox_env["APPDATA"]           = str(tmp_path / "AppData" / "Roaming")
        sandbox_env["LOCALAPPDATA"]      = str(tmp_path / "AppData" / "Local")
        sandbox_env["TEMP"] = sandbox_env["TMP"] = str(tmp_path / "Temp")
        for p in (sandbox_env["APPDATA"], sandbox_env["LOCALAPPDATA"], sandbox_env["TEMP"]):
            os.makedirs(p, exist_ok=True)
    
        if not APP_TITLE:
            pytest.exit("APP_TITLE environment variable is not set", returncode=1)
    
        # shlex.split handles quoted args with spaces; plain split() breaks on them
        import shlex
        # Launch via subprocess so we can pass env; connect pywinauto by PID
        proc = subprocess.Popen(
            [APP_PATH] + shlex.split(APP_ARGS),
            env=sandbox_env,
        )
        pw_app = Application(backend="uia").connect(process=proc.pid, timeout=LAUNCH_TIMEOUT)
        win    = pw_app.window(title=APP_TITLE)
        win.wait("visible", timeout=LAUNCH_TIMEOUT)
        yield win
    
        if getattr(getattr(request.node, "rep_call", None), "failed", False):
            os.makedirs(ARTIFACT_DIR, exist_ok=True)
            try:
                win.capture_as_image().save(
                    os.path.join(ARTIFACT_DIR, f"FAIL_{request.node.name}.png")
                )
            except Exception:
                pass
        try:
            win.close()
            proc.wait(timeout=5)
        except Exception:
            proc.kill()
        # tmp_path is cleaned up automatically by pytest
    
    @pytest.hookimpl(tryfirst=True, hookwrapper=True)
    def pytest_runtest_makereport(item, call):
        outcome = yield
        setattr(item, f"rep_{outcome.get_result().when}", outcome.get_result())
    

    Tier 2 — Windows Job Object (optional: process-lifetime containment)

    Attach the process to a Job Object so it is automatically terminated when the test fixture's job handle is GC'd. Also prevents the app from spawning child processes that escape fixture cleanup.

    Scope of isolation: Job Objects do NOT virtualize filesystem access or block network traffic. File-write and network isolation require AppContainer, Windows Firewall rules, or Tier 3 (Windows Sandbox). Use Tier 2 only for process-lifetime and child-process containment.

    Requires no extra dependencies.

    import ctypes, ctypes.wintypes as wt
    
    def restrict_process(pid: int):
        """
        Attach the process to a Job Object that prevents it from:
        - spawning processes outside the job (LIMIT_KILL_ON_JOB_CLOSE)
        Does NOT block network — use Windows Firewall rules for that.
        """
        JOB_OBJECT_LIMIT_KILL_ON_JOB_CLOSE = 0x00002000
        # Minimal rights: SET_QUOTA (0x0100) | TERMINATE (0x0001)
        PROCESS_SET_QUOTA_AND_TERMINATE    = 0x0101
    
        kernel32 = ctypes.windll.kernel32
        job   = kernel32.CreateJobObjectW(None, None)
        hproc = kernel32.OpenProcess(PROCESS_SET_QUOTA_AND_TERMINATE, False, pid)
    
        # Correct struct layout — LimitFlags is at offset +16, not +44
        class JOBOBJECT_BASIC_LIMIT_INFORMATION(ctypes.Structure):
            _fields_ = [
                ("PerProcessUserTimeLimit", wt.LARGE_INTEGER),
                ("PerJobUserTimeLimit",     wt.LARGE_INTEGER),
                ("LimitFlags",             wt.DWORD),
                ("MinimumWorkingSetSize",   ctypes.c_size_t),
                ("MaximumWorkingSetSize",   ctypes.c_size_t),
                ("ActiveProcessLimit",      wt.DWORD),
                ("Affinity",               ctypes.c_size_t),
                ("PriorityClass",          wt.DWORD),
                ("SchedulingClass",        wt.DWORD),
            ]
    
        info = JOBOBJECT_BASIC_LIMIT_INFORMATION()
        info.LimitFlags = JOB_OBJECT_LIMIT_KILL_ON_JOB_CLOSE
        ok = kernel32.SetInformationJobObject(job, 2, ctypes.byref(info), ctypes.sizeof(info))
        if not ok:
            raise ctypes.WinError()
        kernel32.AssignProcessToJobObject(job, hproc)
        kernel32.CloseHandle(hproc)
        return job  # keep alive — job closes (kills proc) when GC'd
    
    # After proc = subprocess.Popen(...):  job = restrict_process(proc.pid)
    

    Tier 3 — Windows Sandbox (CI full-OS isolation)

    When you need a clean Windows image per run (no leftover registry keys, no shared GPU state, true isolation), run the entire test suite inside Windows Sandbox.

    Requirement: Windows 10/11 Pro or Enterprise, Virtualization enabled.

    Create e2e-sandbox.wsb in your project root:

    <Configuration>
      <MappedFolders>
        <!-- App binary (read-only) -->
        <MappedFolder>
          <HostFolder>C:\path\to\your\build\Release</HostFolder>
          <SandboxFolder>C:\app</SandboxFolder>
          <ReadOnly>true</ReadOnly>
        </MappedFolder>
        <!-- Test suite (read-write for artifacts) -->
        <MappedFolder>
          <HostFolder>C:\path\to\your\e2e_test</HostFolder>
          <SandboxFolder>C:\e2e_test</SandboxFolder>
          <ReadOnly>false</ReadOnly>
        </MappedFolder>
      </MappedFolders>
      <LogonCommand>
        <!--
          Windows Sandbox starts with no Python. Install it silently first,
          then install deps and run tests. Artifacts are written back to the
          host via the MappedFolder above.
        -->
        <Command>powershell -Command "
          winget install --id Python.Python.3.11 --silent --accept-package-agreements;
          $env:PATH += ';' + $env:LOCALAPPDATA + '\Programs\Python\Python311\Scripts';
          cd C:\e2e_test;
          pip install -r requirements.txt;
          pytest tests\ -v
        "</Command>
      </LogonCommand>
    </Configuration>
    

    Launch: WindowsSandbox.exe e2e-sandbox.wsb

    pywinauto and the app both run inside the sandbox (same session required). Artifacts are written back to the host via the mapped folder.

    Tier comparison

    TierIsolationSetup costWorks on CIUse when
    1 — tmp_path env redirectFilesystemZeroAlwaysDefault for all tests
    2 — Job ObjectProcess treeLowAlwaysPrevent child-process escape
    3 — Windows SandboxFull OSMediumNeeds Pro/Enterprise imageNightly clean-room runs

    Prevent hanging tests

    Add pytest-timeout to cap any single test. In pytest.ini set timeout = 60 and timeout_method = thread. Note: thread method cannot kill Qt app subprocesses on Windows — add atexit.register(lambda: [p.kill() for p in psutil.Process().children(recursive=True)]) in conftest.py to reap orphans.

    CI/CD Integration

    # .github/workflows/e2e-desktop.yml
    name: Desktop E2E
    on: [push, pull_request]
    
    jobs:
      e2e:
        runs-on: windows-latest   # real GUI environment, no Xvfb needed
        steps:
          - uses: actions/checkout@v4
    
          - uses: actions/setup-python@v5
            with: { python-version: "3.11" }
    
          - name: Install deps
            run: pip install pywinauto pytest pytest-html Pillow
    
          - name: Build app
            run: cmake --build build --config Release  # adjust to your build system
    
          - name: Run E2E
            env:
              APP_PATH: ${{ github.workspace }}\build\Release\MyApp.exe
              APP_TITLE: "My Application"
              CI: "true"
            run: pytest tests/ --html=artifacts/report.html --self-contained-html --junitxml=artifacts/results.xml -v
    
          - uses: actions/upload-artifact@v4
            if: always()
            with:
              name: e2e-artifacts
              path: artifacts/
              retention-days: 14
    

    Qt Specific

    Enable UIA in Qt 5.x

    Qt 5.x accessibility is disabled by default in some builds (especially 5.7–5.14). Set the environment variable before launching. Qt 6.x enables accessibility by default — skip this step for Qt 6.

    # conftest.py — add at module top
    import os
    os.environ["QT_ACCESSIBILITY"] = "1"
    

    Or export it in CI:

    env:
      QT_ACCESSIBILITY: "1"
    

    Add Stable Identifiers to Qt Widgets

    // Preferred: both objectName and accessibleName
    void setTestId(QWidget* w, const char* id) {
        w->setObjectName(id);
        w->setAccessibleName(id);  // becomes UIA Name property
    }
    
    // In your dialog constructor:
    setTestId(ui->usernameEdit, "usernameInput");
    setTestId(ui->passwordEdit, "passwordInput");
    setTestId(ui->loginButton,  "btnLogin");
    setTestId(ui->errorLabel,   "lblError");
    

    Centralise all IDs in a header to avoid typos:

    // test_ids.h
    #define TID_USERNAME   "usernameInput"
    #define TID_PASSWORD   "passwordInput"
    #define TID_BTN_LOGIN  "btnLogin"
    #define TID_LBL_ERROR  "lblError"
    

    Qt-Specific Quirks

    QComboBox — the dropdown is a separate top-level window:

    from pywinauto import Desktop
    
    def select_combo_item(page, combo_spec, item_text):
        page.click(combo_spec)
        # Dropdown appears as a new root-level window
        # class_name varies by Qt version — verify with Accessibility Insights
        # Qt 5.x: "Qt5QWindowIcon"  |  Qt 6.x: "Qt6QWindowIcon" — verify with Accessibility Insights
        popup = Desktop(backend="uia").window(class_name_re="Qt[56]QWindowIcon")
        popup.wait("visible", timeout=5)
        popup.child_window(title=item_text).click_input()
    

    QMessageBox / QDialog — also separate top-level windows:

    dlg = page.wait_window("Confirm")          # wait for dialog title
    dlg.child_window(title="OK").click_input() # click button inside it
    

    QTableWidget / QTableView — row/cell access:

    table = page.by_id("tblUsers").wrapper_object()
    cell  = table.cell(row=0, column=1)
    print(cell.window_text())
    

    Self-drawn controls (paintEvent-only, QGraphicsView, QOpenGLWidget) — UIA cannot see their internals. Use the Fallback section below.

    Fallback: Screenshot Mode

    When a control is not reachable via UIA (self-drawn, third-party, game engine):

    pip install pyautogui Pillow opencv-python
    
    import pyautogui, cv2, numpy as np
    from PIL import Image
    
    def find_image_on_screen(template_path, confidence=0.85):
        """Locate a template image on screen. Returns (x, y) center or None."""
        screen   = np.array(pyautogui.screenshot())
        template = np.array(Image.open(template_path))
        result   = cv2.matchTemplate(
            cv2.cvtColor(screen, cv2.COLOR_RGB2BGR),
            cv2.cvtColor(template, cv2.COLOR_RGB2BGR),
            cv2.TM_CCOEFF_NORMED,
        )
        _, max_val, _, max_loc = cv2.minMaxLoc(result)
        if max_val >= confidence:
            h, w = template.shape[:2]
            return max_loc[0] + w // 2, max_loc[1] + h // 2
        return None
    
    def click_image(template_path, confidence=0.85):
        pos = find_image_on_screen(template_path, confidence)
        if pos is None:
            raise RuntimeError(f"Image not found on screen: {template_path}")
        pyautogui.click(*pos)
    

    DPI / Scaling Rules (screenshot mode only)

    Screenshot matching is brutally sensitive to Windows display scaling (100% / 125% / 150%). Three hard rules:

    1. Capture templates at the same scale as the target machine. Don't try to rescue a mismatch with PIL.Image.resizecv2.matchTemplate is very fragile against resampling artefacts.
    2. Pin the CI display scaling. On windows-latest add a step like Set-DisplayResolution 1920 1080 -Force and disable per-monitor DPI scaling, so screenshot dimensions are reproducible.
    3. Record the scale alongside each artefact. On capture, write GetDpiForWindow(hwnd) / 96 to artifacts/<test>/metadata.json — postmortems become obvious instead of guess-work.

    Process-level DPI awareness (SetProcessDpiAwarenessContext) can conflict with Qt's own DPI handling when the app under test is Qt-based. Prefer "same-scale templates + CI pin" over flipping process-wide DPI mode in fixtures.

    Debugging Match Confidence

    When tuning the confidence threshold, the only sane workflow is to see where the match landed. The helper below is diagnosis-only — do not call it from test code.

    def debug_match(template_path, out="artifacts/match_debug.png", confidence=0.85):
        """Diagnosis-only. Draw the best-match rectangle + score back on the current screen.
    
        NOT for production tests — use when calibrating confidence or chasing false matches.
        """
        import os, cv2, pyautogui, numpy as np
        screen = np.array(pyautogui.screenshot())[:, :, ::-1]
        tpl    = cv2.imread(template_path)
        if tpl is None:
            raise RuntimeError(f"Template unreadable: {template_path}")
        res    = cv2.matchTemplate(screen, tpl, cv2.TM_CCOEFF_NORMED)
        _, mv, _, ml = cv2.minMaxLoc(res)
        h, w   = tpl.shape[:2]
        colour = (0, 255, 0) if mv >= confidence else (0, 0, 255)  # green pass / red fail
        cv2.rectangle(screen, ml, (ml[0]+w, ml[1]+h), colour, 2)
        cv2.putText(screen, f"score={mv:.3f} thr={confidence}",
                    (ml[0], max(20, ml[1]-6)),
                    cv2.FONT_HERSHEY_SIMPLEX, 0.7, colour, 2)
        os.makedirs(os.path.dirname(out) or ".", exist_ok=True)
        cv2.imwrite(out, screen)
        return mv
    

    Use sparingly — image matching breaks on DPI changes, theme switches, and partial occlusion. Always try UIA first; fall back to screenshots only for genuinely unreachable controls.

    Anti-Patterns

    # BAD: fixed sleep
    time.sleep(3)
    page.click(page.by_id("btnSubmit"))
    
    # GOOD: condition wait
    page.wait_visible(page.by_id("btnSubmit"))
    page.click(page.by_id("btnSubmit"))
    
    # BAD: brittle class+index locator as primary strategy
    page.by_class("Edit", index=2).type_keys("hello")
    
    # GOOD: AutomationId
    page.by_id("usernameInput").set_edit_text("hello")
    
    # BAD: assert on pixel coordinates
    assert btn.rectangle().left == 120
    
    # GOOD: assert on content / state
    assert page.get_text(page.by_id("lblStatus")) == "Logged in"
    assert page.by_id("btnLogout").is_enabled()
    
    # BAD: share app instance across all tests (state leaks)
    @pytest.fixture(scope="session")
    def app(): ...
    
    # GOOD: fresh process per test (or per class at most)
    @pytest.fixture(scope="function")
    def app(): ...
    

    Running Tests

    # All tests
    pytest tests/ -v
    
    # Smoke only
    pytest tests/ -m smoke -v
    
    # Specific file
    pytest tests/test_login.py -v
    
    # With custom app path
    APP_PATH="C:\build\Release\MyApp.exe" APP_TITLE="MyApp" pytest tests/ -v
    
    # Detect flaky tests (repeat each 5 times)
    pip install pytest-repeat
    pytest tests/test_login.py --count=5 -v
    

    Related Skills

    • e2e-testing — Playwright E2E for web applications
    • cpp-testing — C++ unit/integration testing with GoogleTest
    • cpp-coding-standards — C++ code style and patterns

    Alternatives

    Compare before choosing